In 1998
Hilary Mantel published a great novel based on the life and times of 18th Century Scottish
surgeon
John Hunter and his anatomist brother William. Hunter was responsible for the original huge collection of pathological specimens now housed at the
Hunterian Museum
at the Royal College of Surgeons in London. The surgeon was keen to obtain specimens
of any and every physiological wonder he could find. In Mantel’s
The Giant, O’Brien, in 1782 we
find that Hunter was pursuing the dying
7 foot 7 inch tall Irish giant,
Charles O’Brien (Bryne)
in order to obtain his skeleton for his collection. He plied the unwilling
O’Brien with promises of a cash advance for his eventual corpse. (see his skeleton in the case: photo at right)
The novel is one of my favorites.
This book paints a detailed
picture of the intrigue and almost desperation that was prevalent during these
times, when medical science was struggling to advance, but access to human cadavers
was scarce. It also describes the intrigue and illegal activity that supported
the men of medicine in the 18th and 19th centuries. There
was a critical shortage of human cadavers for teaching and research before the
Anatomy Act of 1832 opened the
poorhouse doors to give access to those too poor to afford a proper burial. Until then, the few legal bodies that were available from hanged criminals were
not enough for the growing number of anatomy schools. Soon the
Resurrection Men were able to fill the void by
grave robbing and
body snatching for
quick cash.
William Burke and William Hare didn’t take long to evolve into murderers when they realized how easy it was
to cash in by selling cadavers to Dr. Robert Knox, an ambitious Edinburgh
anatomist. In 1828, after 16 murders over an 11-month period, they were caught
and Burke was hanged AND anatomized. The verb to be
burked or
burking entered
the English language. Director John Landis is about to complete a new film
(2010) —
Burke and Hare,
one of many such films made about them over the years.
I found a recent documentary
film about body snatching that is strangely reminiscent of a 1987 episode,
“Body Banks”, of the quirky sci-fi television show
Max Headroom.
The documentary by the BBC’s Horizon examines the high monetary value of the human
remains needed for research, testing, study, and medical transplant and how this
results in the illicit trafficking of such remains.
This is all very different from
the live organ donations that are much more regulated and controlled by the
in-hospital context in which they are harvested. See
Organ Donation and Transplantation from the
Encyclopedia of Death and Dying website.
BBC/Horizon promotional
text for the documentary:
How Much is Your Dead Body Worth?
When veteran broadcaster Alistair Cooke died in 2004 few suspected that he was yet
to uncover his greatest story. What happened to his body as it lay in a funeral
home would reveal a story of modern day grave robbery and helped smash a
body-snatching ring that had made millions of dollars by chopping up and
selling-off over 1000 bodies. Dead bodies have become big business. Each year
millions of people’s lives are improved by the use of tissue from the dead.
Bodies are used to supply spare parts, and for surgeons to practice on. Horizon
investigates the medical revolution that has created an almost insatiable
demand for body parts and uncovers the growing industry and grisly black market
that supplies human bodies for a price.
Watch it in its entirety at
Top Documentary Films.
How Much Is Your Dead Body Worth? BBC-UK 49:00 min
***WARNING – Contains
Scenes Of Human Dissection and Human Body Parts***
… well worth the watch, though.